The Tale of Carroll Rudy

Story and photos by Todd Cotgreave

Introduction


I was driving on old but familiar roads in Hardy County West Virginia trying to figure out what this magazine was going to be about when I saw an old grocery store that has been closed for as long as I can remember. My hands (seemingly acting on their own) were already pulling into the driveway as I noticed and elderly man wearing cutoffs pulling a lawnmower out of his shed. I hopped out and introduced myself, which is to say, I could barely introduce myself. I had no magazine title yet, no business card, no old copies of my work, no credibility to ask what so easily came out of my mouth,

“Hi, I’m Todd. Mind if I ask you some questions and take your picture?”
The man replied, “If you’re going to take pictures, my lady friend is going to want to be in them, hold on a minute,”

Reality kicked in, what am I doing pulling into a random person’s house just asking to invade their privacy and interrupt their day? I must be crazy! This was also the first step (although at this moment I hadn’t pieced it together yet) into remembering that West Virginians are just plain… well… they are just plain friendly. Call it old fashioned, call it country, call it what you will but within a minute the man walked back out of his house… lady friend in tow and said,

“I’m Carroll Rudy, that’s with two R’s and two L’s. How can we help you?”

The conversation was so easy and pleasant. He introduced me to his girlfriend Catherine Painter, and we set about talking and looking at how beautiful it was there. He mentioned that land was so pretty, it was once on the cover of the phone book. Ten to fifteen minutes into chatting he paused and took a deep, long look at me and said,

“We’re getting to be friends wouldn’t you think?”

“I’d like to think so, yes.”

He got closer and looked directly into my eyes and said softly, as if to share a secret, “Well friends of mine can fish here anytime they want.”

He yelled for Catherine to run and get something be she cut him off mid ask, “I got it already. I figured you were going to ask for it.”

She handed him the world’s smallest notebook and he wrote me a note on it. It read: “I give permission to Todd to fish on my property. Signed Carroll Rudy”. It was about the nicest, and sweetest thing I’ve ever been a part of. *

“This way, if you’re out here fishing and the state police come up on you, you just show them this, and you’ll be fine. They can’t do a thing to you.”

I would say yes, most definitely yes, we were friends. How can you not be friends with someone that opens their home and life to you after just having met a few minutes prior? You can say a bit of my faith in humanity was restored right then and there.

We talked for a few hours and walked all over the property discussing life past and present in his tiny town of McCauley. One of the nicest parts was being invited back to go for a hike up the mountain where his old TV antenna sits. He said there was a beautiful view that I just had to see.

I can’t wait. But until then, here is the beginning of our magazine a Wide Place in the Road and the tale of Carroll Rudy

*For those unfamiliar, fishing rights are a big deal in WV. 90% of the land is private, and most keep a watch out to make sure no one will fish out their favorite spot. Offering a note with lifetime access is akin to handing over the keys to a Cadillac.


The Tale of Carroll Rudy

Carroll Rudy lives in a place so remote even the rivers get lost. McCauley, West Virginia is just southeast of where the Lost River flows underground only later to emerge with its name changed to the Capon River. Last year McCauley had an estimated population of 3. It’s as remote as it is beautiful, but if you want to fish the river, you’d better be friends with Carroll before you go as he routinely “patrols” the riverside for trespassers.

Born in a house at Baughman Settlement, which is another similar sized town less than 3 miles from McCauley, Carroll has been everywhere and done about everything a person could do growing up in Hardy County.

“A lot of this is going to be hard to believe but it’s fact.” Carroll says about all the places he worked and lived.

One of his first jobs (while he was still in primary school) was raising over one hundred chickens all on his own. He was up every day before sunrise, and back again in the evening to take care of them and make sure they were fed and healthy. He wasn’t paid for it, he did as a way to help his parents out. During his teenager years he put many miles on his bicycle by delivering both household items for Blair Products, and by selling copies of Grit magazine. Not that he wasn’t busy enough doing that, he would also be up before dawn, but this time instead of raising chickens, he was employed to catch them. Catch them by the truckload that is,

“We got paid four dollars a load, didn’t make a damn whether it was a trailer load or truck load, we got paid the same.”

After catching them by hand and loading them, he would ride with the driver as they delivered to places like Franklin, WV or Harrisionburg, VA. He would even go on the long trips up to New York so he could see new places and because the driver would let him drive the truck. Depending on how far away the delivery was, he would either be dropped off at home or close enough that he could walk to school.

A week after graduating from high school, the country was in a recession and Carroll volunteered for the draft.

“Jobs were hard to come by and if you didn’t have the military behind you, forget about it.”

The local handyman stops to discuss a house project.

After his time in the service, he lived everywhere from Cumberland and Keyser to Winchester and Hagerstown. He worked several different jobs, starting off in a shoe center, then onto a cabinet factory in Moorefield. He worked next with Montgomery Wards and then for a short time he was at the Allegheny Ballistic Laboratory near Short Gap, WV. He eventually found a career with Potomac Edison, where he worked for thirty-six years before retiring to his hometown Of McCauley.

“I said you better have a lot of paper if you want to know my story!” Laughed Carroll.

One of his favorite pastimes is to travel nearly an hour and a half to watch horse racing at the race track in Charles Town, WV. Not much of a big gambler, he says,

“Just making small bets that could win big.”

Carroll also used the opportunity to stretch his spending dollars at the local Save-a-Lot. Often working the register was Catherine Painter, who said he was a regular customer, but started spending more time talking with her and less time shopping for the essential items he may need.

“She was the main item!” Carroll exclaimed as Catherine told the story of them meeting.

Eventually he gave her his number and asked her to give him a call sometime. Looking at the number every so often, with no intention of making the call, Catherine said one day she didn’t know what came over her, but she called his number and the rest is history.

Now with a population of 4, McCauley is a bustling center of activity and Carroll has it all mapped out,

“At quarter ‘til 12, if it’s in the 60’s I take a two-mile walk, if it’s in the 70’s I mow.” He stated.

Catherine quickly added, “If I don’t sunbathe, he won’t mow!” They both erupted in laughter as Carroll made no attempt to correct her.

Corridor H bridge named in honor of Carroll’s parents

Traveling the area brings them both joy as they attend many dinners, functions, fairs and festivals.

“We were planning on going to the state fair, but they stopped putting out brochures to let you know what’s going on, so we just go to the local ones.”

They live comfortably in his family homestead which sits almost directly under a bridge that is part of the Corridor H system. His parents ran “Rudy’s Grocery” for over 55 years out of it, and it was one of the few places to shop for your essentials for miles in any direction. Carroll said there was a lot of fuss and mess during construction of the behemoth sized bridge, which has been memorialized in his parents John and Freda’s honor. Now complete, the road in front of his house is less traveled than before and as he says it’s, “Much more peaceful because of it.”

You can easily imagine an energetic and active young Carroll Rudy running around Hardy County through his attention to detail in storytelling, and the ever-present light in his eyes as he speaks. There is a sense of gratitude for the life he’s lived, and an expectation for fun and laughter in the days to come. They may have broken the mold when Carroll was made, but I wish they hadn’t, we could use a few more people like him.

A fishing spot so fine it wound up on the phone book